Array
(
[a_id] => 267110
[c_id] => 1
[r_id] => 0
[rr_id] => 0
[m_id] => 0
[s_id] => 25646
[id_id] => 0
[v_id] => 0
[loc_id] => 0
[ft_id] => 0
[a_classification] => news
[a_layout] => 1
[a_headline] => In Lawsuit Over Pregnant Woman’s Right To End Life, Clarity Comes In Short Supply
[a_sheadline] => In Lawsuit Over Pregnant Woman’s Right To End Life, Clarity Comes In Short Supply
[a_slug] => lawsuit-over-pregnant-womans-right-end-life-clarity-comes-short-supply-267110
[a_subheadline] =>
[a_summary] => Erick Munoz has asked a district judge to review the grounds on which John Peter Smith Hospital is keeping his pregnant and brain-dead wife on life-support against her family's wishes.
[a_article] =>
Erick Munoz, the husband of the brain-dead, pregnant Texas woman currently kept on life-support against her family’s wishes, has asked a judge to review the little-known statute that hospital officials say precludes their doctors and staff from honoring his wife’s Do-Not-Resuscitate order.
The complaint, which was filed Tuesday in state district court, charges that John Peter Smith Hospital in Fort Worth, Tex., has no legal right to uphold life-support for Marlise Munoz, a 33-year-old North Texas woman who suffered irreparable brain damage after she was incapacitated by what doctors believe was a blood clot on Nov. 26 last year. It further states that Marlise, who was a paramedic in life, left straight-forward instructions regarding end-of-life issues in the form of a Do-Not-Resuscitate order — a written order that basically tells physicians, doctors, and first responders that this patient doesn’t want anything to do with cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR).
“She gave clear instructions to her husband and family — Marlise was not to remain on any type of artificial 'life sustaining treatment', ventilators or the like," the lawsuit says. "There is no reason JPS should be allowed to continue treatment on Marlise Munoz's dead body, and this Court should order JPS to immediately discontinue such."
Right to Life, Right to Death
Here, however, is where things start to get a little murky. From a legal as well as an ethical standpoint, Marlise is not just any patient, as she was 14 weeks pregnant at the time of her hospitalization. In a state where lawmakers recently enacted what some have called the most prohibitive abortion restrictions in the nation, this is a problem.
Hospital officials claim that, under Texas end-of-life guidelines, the Do-Not-Resuscitate order on file is no good, as it is overridden by a state statute whereby pregnant patients cannot be denied life-support. In the eyes of the law, they say, Marlise is not a vegetative patient subject to her family’s wishes, but a mother-to-be protected by the Texas Advance Directives Act. "This is not a difficult decision for us,” hospital spokesperson J.R. Labbe told the Associated Press. “We are following the law."
Counsel for Munoz as well as a number of legal experts retort that, in the eyes of the law, Marlise is actually neither a pregnant woman nor a vegetative patient, but a dead body. They argue that, if the present quandary is to be reduced to a two-dimensional law school question, it follows that Marlise must assume the role she would have in a court of law: a legally dead entity. As such, she is not protected under the Texas Advance Directives Act, as the statute — like most other statutes — only applies for the living.
"This patient is neither terminally nor irreversibly ill," Dr. Robert Fine, clinical director of the office of clinical ethics and palliative care for Baylor Health Care System, told reporters last week. "Under Texas law, this patient is legally dead."
In addition, husband Erick Munoz and other critics of the hospital’s stance point to the questionable viability of the unborn fetus that is now entering its 20th week of gestation. Although doctors say they are monitoring the unborn child’s development, Erick, who is also a paramedic, is afraid his wife’s injuries may not be limited to her own body. "You know what kind of damage my wife sustained, and what kind of possible damage the baby inside her sustained," he told reporters.
An Easier Way Out
As we cede these ethical and legal issues to the state judiciary, two things seem clear. First, given the relatively staunch position of both parties, the lawsuit at hand may be the easiest way out of a situation that could otherwise get very messy very quickly. After all, both sides are trying to protect what they value over most things: the hospital is fighting for its patient care policy, and Erick is fighting for the mother of his child. A drawn-out dispute would be in no one’s interest.
Second, while the present suit may be the most sensible option, it risks pitting against each other two parties that really don’t want any trouble at all. There is a case to be made that the hospital, in refusing to pull Marlise’s life support, is not advancing an uncompromising pro-life agenda, but simply hedging itself against third-party litigants. Tom Mayo, a professor of law at Southern Methodist University, told reporters in early January that if the hospital was to honor Marlise’s Do-Not-Resuscitate order, it would itself run the risk of civil and even criminal liability under the Texas Advance Directives Act.
And if such liability would be established, the hospital could face litigation from anti-abortion activists and pro-life groups — foes with longer arms and deeper pockets than a 26-year-old single father who just wants to bury his wife, return to his 15-month-old son, and resume his life as a paramedic in North Texas.
[c_iab] =>
[c_order] => 0
[c_allow] => 1
[c_time] => 0000-00-00 00:00:00
[c_country] =>
[tid] => 2
[c_parent] => Array
(
[0] => 2
)
[c_path] => Array
(
[0] => Policy/Biz
)
[c_status] => Array
(
[0] => 1
)
[c_path_slug] => Array
(
[0] => policy-biz
)
[w] =>
[h] =>
)
)
[reporters] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
)
)
[reviews] => Array
(
)
[s_name] => Medical Daily
[s_slug] => medical-daily
[s_credit] => Published by Medicaldaily.com
[web_id] => 0
[s_aid] => 0
[cen_s_id] => 0
[s_url] =>
[s_order] => 0
[s_photo] =>
[s_allow] => 1
[a_facebook] => 0
[a_twitter] => 0
[a_plus] => 0
[a_linkedin] => 0
[a_reddit] => 0
[a_views] => 1
[r_headline] => In Lawsuit Over Pregnant Woman’s Right To End Life, Clarity Comes In Short Supply
[a_error] => 0
[a_search] => In Lawsuit Over Pregnant Woman’s Right To End Life, Clarity Comes In Short Supply
[a_h1] =>
[a_standout] => 0
[a_standouted] => 0
[a_special] =>
[a_rshare] => 0
[a_applenews_id] =>
[a_applenews_revision] =>
[a_url_slug] =>
[a_noindex] => 0
[a_link] =>
[a_syndication] => 1
[a_meta_description] =>
[a_key_points] =>
[a_tier] =>
[a_value1] =>
[a_value2] => 0
[a_weight] => 0
[a_whitelist] => 1
[a_permanant_whitelist] => 0
[a_parent_id] => 0
[a_web_id] => 0
[a_rank] => 0
[a_ads] => 1
[a_google_ai] => 0
[a_disclaimer] => 1
[a_cloudsearch] => 0
[a_json] =>
[keywords] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[k_id] => 3522
[k_keyword] => Pregnancy
[k_page_title] =>
[k_meta_description] => Pregnancy is the fertilization and development of one or more offspring, known as an embryo or fetus, in a woman's uterus. In a pregnancy, there can be multiple gestations, as in the case of twins or triplets. Childbirth usually occurs about 38 weeks afte
[k_slug] => pregnancy
[k_type] => 0
[id_id] =>
[file_id] => 0
[c_id] => 0
[m_id] => 1
[k_text] => Pregnancy is the fertilization and development of one or more offspring, known as an embryo or fetus, in a woman's uterus. In a pregnancy, there can be multiple gestations, as in the case of twins or triplets. Childbirth usually occurs about 38 weeks after conception; in women who have a menstrual cycle length of four weeks, this is approximately 40 weeks from the start of the last normal menstrual period.
[k_tree] => 3522
[k_parent_id] => 0
[k_ancestry] => -3522-
[k_level] => 0
[k_article] =>
[k_allow] => 2
[k_time] => 2019-11-13 09:49:36
[k_photo] =>
[k_tid] => 26593
[k_tslug] => conditions/pregnancy
[k_approved] => 0
)
[1] => Array
(
[k_id] => 28221
[k_keyword] => Erick munoz
[k_page_title] =>
[k_meta_description] =>
[k_slug] => erick-munoz
[k_type] => 0
[id_id] =>
[file_id] =>
[c_id] => 0
[m_id] => 1
[k_text] =>
[k_tree] => 28221
[k_parent_id] => 0
[k_ancestry] => -28221-
[k_level] => 0
[k_article] =>
[k_allow] => 1
[k_time] => 2014-01-14 19:45:21
[k_photo] =>
[k_tid] => 0
[k_tslug] =>
[k_approved] => 0
)
[2] => Array
(
[k_id] => 28624
[k_keyword] => Marlise munoz life support
[k_page_title] =>
[k_meta_description] =>
[k_slug] => marlise-munoz-life-support
[k_type] => 0
[id_id] =>
[file_id] =>
[c_id] => 0
[m_id] => 1
[k_text] =>
[k_tree] => 28624
[k_parent_id] => 0
[k_ancestry] => -28624-
[k_level] => 0
[k_article] =>
[k_allow] => 1
[k_time] => 2014-01-14 19:45:21
[k_photo] =>
[k_tid] => 0
[k_tslug] =>
[k_approved] => 0
)
[3] => Array
(
[k_id] => 28625
[k_keyword] => Pregnant woman life support
[k_page_title] =>
[k_meta_description] =>
[k_slug] => pregnant-woman-life-support
[k_type] => 0
[id_id] =>
[file_id] =>
[c_id] => 0
[m_id] => 1
[k_text] =>
[k_tree] => 28625
[k_parent_id] => 0
[k_ancestry] => -28625-
[k_level] => 0
[k_article] =>
[k_allow] => 1
[k_time] => 2014-01-14 19:45:21
[k_photo] =>
[k_tid] => 0
[k_tslug] =>
[k_approved] => 0
)
[4] => Array
(
[k_id] => 28626
[k_keyword] => John peter smith hospital
[k_page_title] =>
[k_meta_description] =>
[k_slug] => john-peter-smith-hospital
[k_type] => 0
[id_id] =>
[file_id] =>
[c_id] => 0
[m_id] => 1
[k_text] =>
[k_tree] => 28626
[k_parent_id] => 0
[k_ancestry] => -28626-
[k_level] => 0
[k_article] =>
[k_allow] => 1
[k_time] => 2014-01-14 19:45:21
[k_photo] =>
[k_tid] => 0
[k_tslug] =>
[k_approved] => 0
)
[5] => Array
(
[k_id] => 28627
[k_keyword] => Pregnant texas woman brain dead
[k_page_title] =>
[k_meta_description] =>
[k_slug] => pregnant-texas-woman-brain-dead
[k_type] => 0
[id_id] =>
[file_id] =>
[c_id] => 0
[m_id] => 1
[k_text] =>
[k_tree] => 28627
[k_parent_id] => 0
[k_ancestry] => -28627-
[k_level] => 0
[k_article] =>
[k_allow] => 1
[k_time] => 2014-01-14 19:45:21
[k_photo] =>
[k_tid] => 0
[k_tslug] =>
[k_approved] => 0
)
)
[shorten] =>
[locations] => Array
(
)
[related] => Array
(
)
[channels] => Array
(
)
[graphic] => Array
(
)
[feature] => Array
(
)
[topics] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[k_id] => 3522
[k_keyword] => Pregnancy
[k_page_title] =>
[k_meta_description] => Pregnancy is the fertilization and development of one or more offspring, known as an embryo or fetus, in a woman's uterus. In a pregnancy, there can be multiple gestations, as in the case of twins or triplets. Childbirth usually occurs about 38 weeks afte
[k_slug] => pregnancy
[k_type] => 0
[id_id] =>
[file_id] => 0
[c_id] => 0
[m_id] => 1
[k_text] => Pregnancy is the fertilization and development of one or more offspring, known as an embryo or fetus, in a woman's uterus. In a pregnancy, there can be multiple gestations, as in the case of twins or triplets. Childbirth usually occurs about 38 weeks after conception; in women who have a menstrual cycle length of four weeks, this is approximately 40 weeks from the start of the last normal menstrual period.
[k_tree] => 3522
[k_parent_id] => 0
[k_ancestry] => -3522-
[k_level] => 0
[k_article] =>
[k_allow] => 2
[k_time] => 2019-11-13 09:49:36
[k_photo] =>
[k_tid] => 26593
[k_tslug] => conditions/pregnancy
[k_approved] => 0
[k_count] => 1164
)
)
[first_info] => Array
(
[eh_id] => 31387
[eh_what] => article
[a_id] => 267110
[eh_type] => imageBox
[eh_align] => block
[eh_width] => 736
[eh_height] =>
[eh_w] => 736
[eh_h] => 0
[eh_position] => -2
[eh_text] =>
[eh_parent] => 0
[eh_num] => 0
[eh_time] => 2014-01-14 19:45:21
[eh_x1] => 267109
[eh_d1] => 267109
[eh_d2] =>
[eh_d3] => Erick Munoz has asked a district judge to review the grounds on which John Peter Smith Hospital is keeping his pregnant and brain-dead wife on life-support against her family's wishes.
[eh_d4] =>
[eh_d5] => texas capitol
[eh_d6] =>
[eh_d7] =>
[eh_d8] =>
[eh_d9] =>
[eh_d10] =>
[eh_d11] =>
)
[review_item] => Array
(
)
[a_content_first] =>
Erick Munoz has asked a district judge to review the grounds on which John Peter Smith Hospital is keeping his pregnant and brain-dead wife on life-support against her family's wishes.Texas Capitol Image via Shutterstock
[a_content] =>
Erick Munoz, the husband of the brain-dead, pregnant Texas woman currently kept on life-support against her family’s wishes, has asked a judge to review the little-known statute that hospital officials say precludes their doctors and staff from honoring his wife’s Do-Not-Resuscitate order.
The complaint, which was filed Tuesday in state district court, charges that John Peter Smith Hospital in Fort Worth, Tex., has no legal right to uphold life-support for Marlise Munoz, a 33-year-old North Texas woman who suffered irreparable brain damage after she was incapacitated by what doctors believe was a blood clot on Nov. 26 last year. It further states that Marlise, who was a paramedic in life, left straight-forward instructions regarding end-of-life issues in the form of a Do-Not-Resuscitate order — a written order that basically tells physicians, doctors, and first responders that this patient doesn’t want anything to do with cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR).
“She gave clear instructions to her husband and family — Marlise was not to remain on any type of artificial 'life sustaining treatment', ventilators or the like," the lawsuit says. "There is no reason JPS should be allowed to continue treatment on Marlise Munoz's dead body, and this Court should order JPS to immediately discontinue such."
Right to Life, Right to Death
Here, however, is where things start to get a little murky. From a legal as well as an ethical standpoint, Marlise is not just any patient, as she was 14 weeks pregnant at the time of her hospitalization. In a state where lawmakers recently enacted what some have called the most prohibitive abortion restrictions in the nation, this is a problem.
Hospital officials claim that, under Texas end-of-life guidelines, the Do-Not-Resuscitate order on file is no good, as it is overridden by a state statute whereby pregnant patients cannot be denied life-support. In the eyes of the law, they say, Marlise is not a vegetative patient subject to her family’s wishes, but a mother-to-be protected by the Texas Advance Directives Act. "This is not a difficult decision for us,” hospital spokesperson J.R. Labbe told the Associated Press. “We are following the law."
Counsel for Munoz as well as a number of legal experts retort that, in the eyes of the law, Marlise is actually neither a pregnant woman nor a vegetative patient, but a dead body. They argue that, if the present quandary is to be reduced to a two-dimensional law school question, it follows that Marlise must assume the role she would have in a court of law: a legally dead entity. As such, she is not protected under the Texas Advance Directives Act, as the statute — like most other statutes — only applies for the living.
"This patient is neither terminally nor irreversibly ill," Dr. Robert Fine, clinical director of the office of clinical ethics and palliative care for Baylor Health Care System, told reporters last week. "Under Texas law, this patient is legally dead."
In addition, husband Erick Munoz and other critics of the hospital’s stance point to the questionable viability of the unborn fetus that is now entering its 20th week of gestation. Although doctors say they are monitoring the unborn child’s development, Erick, who is also a paramedic, is afraid his wife’s injuries may not be limited to her own body. "You know what kind of damage my wife sustained, and what kind of possible damage the baby inside her sustained," he told reporters.
An Easier Way Out
As we cede these ethical and legal issues to the state judiciary, two things seem clear. First, given the relatively staunch position of both parties, the lawsuit at hand may be the easiest way out of a situation that could otherwise get very messy very quickly. After all, both sides are trying to protect what they value over most things: the hospital is fighting for its patient care policy, and Erick is fighting for the mother of his child. A drawn-out dispute would be in no one’s interest.
Second, while the present suit may be the most sensible option, it risks pitting against each other two parties that really don’t want any trouble at all. There is a case to be made that the hospital, in refusing to pull Marlise’s life support, is not advancing an uncompromising pro-life agenda, but simply hedging itself against third-party litigants. Tom Mayo, a professor of law at Southern Methodist University, told reporters in early January that if the hospital was to honor Marlise’s Do-Not-Resuscitate order, it would itself run the risk of civil and even criminal liability under the Texas Advance Directives Act.
And if such liability would be established, the hospital could face litigation from anti-abortion activists and pro-life groups — foes with longer arms and deeper pockets than a 26-year-old single father who just wants to bury his wife, return to his 15-month-old son, and resume his life as a paramedic in North Texas.
[a_content_last] =>
[a_aside] =>
[a_content_first_type] => imageBox
[a_content_last_type] =>
[a_content_embed] =>
[image] => Array
(
[id_id] => 267109
[id_name] => texas capitol
[id_caption] => Erick Munoz has asked a district judge to review the grounds on which John Peter Smith Hospital is keeping his pregnant and brain-dead wife on life-support against her family's wishes.
[id_short_caption] =>
[id_credit] => Texas Capitol Image via Shutterstock
[id_keyword] =>
[id_gallery] =>
[id_adult] => 0
[id_hide] => 0
[id_source] =>
[id_photographer] =>
[id_text] =>
[id_ext] => jpg
[id_location] =>
[id_width] => 1000
[id_height] => 667
[id_left] => 50
[id_top] => 40
[id_quality] => 85
[id_filesize] => 72209
[s_id] =>
[m_id] => 71
[x_id] => 0
[id_time] => 2014-01-14 19:36:38
[id_submittedTime] => 2014-01-14 19:36:38
[id_url] =>
[id_published] => 1
[img_name] => public://2014/01/14/texas-capitol.jpg
[ori] => https://d.medicaldaily.com/en/full/267109/texas-capitol.jpg
[src] => https://d.medicaldaily.com/en/full/267109/texas-capitol.jpg
[tag] => src="https://d.medicaldaily.com/en/full/267109/texas-capitol.jpg" alt="texas capitol"
[picture] =>
)
[images] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[id_id] => 267109
[id_name] => texas capitol
[id_caption] => Erick Munoz has asked a district judge to review the grounds on which John Peter Smith Hospital is keeping his pregnant and brain-dead wife on life-support against her family's wishes.
[id_short_caption] =>
[id_credit] => Texas Capitol Image via Shutterstock
[id_keyword] =>
[id_gallery] =>
[id_adult] => 0
[id_hide] => 0
[id_source] =>
[id_photographer] =>
[id_text] =>
[id_ext] => jpg
[id_location] =>
[id_width] => 1000
[id_height] => 667
[id_left] => 50
[id_top] => 40
[id_quality] => 85
[id_filesize] => 72209
[s_id] =>
[m_id] => 71
[x_id] => 0
[id_time] => 2014-01-14 19:36:38
[id_submittedTime] => 2014-01-14 19:36:38
[id_url] =>
[id_published] => 1
[img_name] => public://2014/01/14/texas-capitol.jpg
[ori] => https://d.medicaldaily.com/en/full/267109/texas-capitol.jpg
[src] => https://d.medicaldaily.com/en/full/267109/texas-capitol.jpg
[tag] => src="https://d.medicaldaily.com/en/full/267109/texas-capitol.jpg" alt="texas capitol"
[picture] =>
)
)
[a_adult] => 0
[mainCat] => Array
(
[c_id] => 1
[c_type] => 1
[c_name] => US/World
[c_slug] => us-world
[c_ancestry] => -1-
[c_ancestry_slug] =>
[c_parent_id] => 0
[x_id] => 0
[c_text] =>
[c_iab] =>
[c_order] => 0
[c_allow] => 1
[c_time] => 0000-00-00 00:00:00
[c_country] =>
[tid] => 1
)
[sym_cat] => US/World
[olink] => https://www.medicaldaily.com/lawsuit-over-pregnant-womans-right-end-life-clarity-comes-short-supply-267110
[related_video] => Array
(
)
[videos] => Array
(
)
[associated] => Array
(
)
[a_val] => 0
[breadcrumb] => Array
(
[@context] => http://schema.org
[@type] => BreadcrumbList
[itemListElement] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[@type] => ListItem
[position] => 1
[name] => US/World
[item] => https://www.medicaldaily.com/us-world
)
[1] => Array
(
[@type] => ListItem
[position] => 2
[name] => Pregnancy
[item] => https://www.medicaldaily.com/conditions/pregnancy
)
)
)
)
In Lawsuit Over Pregnant Woman’s Right To End Life, Clarity Comes In Short Supply
The study also revealed that individuals who quit smoking, regardless of age, can achieve a life expectancy similar to non-smokers within approximately 10 years after quitting, and nearly half of this benefit can be noticed within just three years.
Researchers found that a combination of genetics and environmental factors reduces longevity in dementia patients. The same combination may shorten the lives of their siblings even without dementia.
The suicide rates increase substantially when air pollution rises, and the effect was particularly strong in the elderly, with older women 2.5 times more at risk than other groups.
While mental stress is commonly acknowledged in connection with grief, it is crucial to understand that grief can also present physical symptoms, including illnesses, fatigue, pain, and sleep disturbances.
The use of antidepressants, particularly fluoxetine, could affect the development of the prefrontal cortex of the infant's brain, potentially raising the risk of mental health disorders later in their life.
Researchers have developed smart earrings that could continuously monitor a person's earlobe temperature. The innovation known as Thermal Earring could also be potentially used to track signs of ovulation, stress, eating, and exercise.
The researchers made the interesting finding using a trial involving patients with a rare genetic condition called Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency (AATD).
People infected with the flu were more likely to need hospital care in the following year for common neurologic conditions than people who had the SARS-CoV2 infection.
Among women with a history of pregnancy complications, those who achieved or maintained high heart health after pregnancy were at a similar risk for heart disease as women without adverse pregnancy outcomes and good cardiovascular health, the study stated.
The study published in the journal BMJ indicated that individuals with hypermobile joints had a 30% higher chance of not fully recovering from COVID-19 and experiencing persistent fatigue associated with long COVID.
The studies showed that COVID antigens lingered in the blood up to 14 months after infection and more than two years in tissue samples of people who had the infection.
Those individuals who receive a COVID-19 vaccine during the first half of their menstrual cycle are more likely to experience cycle length changes than those receiving a vaccine in the latter half.
In Lawsuit Over Pregnant Woman’s Right To End Life, Clarity Comes In Short Supply
By
Erick Munoz has asked a district judge to review the grounds on which John Peter Smith Hospital is keeping his pregnant and brain-dead wife on life-support against her family's wishes.Texas Capitol Image via Shutterstock
Erick Munoz, the husband of the brain-dead, pregnant Texas woman currently kept on life-support against her family’s wishes, has asked a judge to review the little-known statute that hospital officials say precludes their doctors and staff from honoring his wife’s Do-Not-Resuscitate order.
The complaint, which was filed Tuesday in state district court, charges that John Peter Smith Hospital in Fort Worth, Tex., has no legal right to uphold life-support for Marlise Munoz, a 33-year-old North Texas woman who suffered irreparable brain damage after she was incapacitated by what doctors believe was a blood clot on Nov. 26 last year. It further states that Marlise, who was a paramedic in life, left straight-forward instructions regarding end-of-life issues in the form of a Do-Not-Resuscitate order — a written order that basically tells physicians, doctors, and first responders that this patient doesn’t want anything to do with cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR).
“She gave clear instructions to her husband and family — Marlise was not to remain on any type of artificial 'life sustaining treatment', ventilators or the like," the lawsuit says. "There is no reason JPS should be allowed to continue treatment on Marlise Munoz's dead body, and this Court should order JPS to immediately discontinue such."
Right to Life, Right to Death
Here, however, is where things start to get a little murky. From a legal as well as an ethical standpoint, Marlise is not just any patient, as she was 14 weeks pregnant at the time of her hospitalization. In a state where lawmakers recently enacted what some have called the most prohibitive abortion restrictions in the nation, this is a problem.
Hospital officials claim that, under Texas end-of-life guidelines, the Do-Not-Resuscitate order on file is no good, as it is overridden by a state statute whereby pregnant patients cannot be denied life-support. In the eyes of the law, they say, Marlise is not a vegetative patient subject to her family’s wishes, but a mother-to-be protected by the Texas Advance Directives Act. "This is not a difficult decision for us,” hospital spokesperson J.R. Labbe told the Associated Press. “We are following the law."
Counsel for Munoz as well as a number of legal experts retort that, in the eyes of the law, Marlise is actually neither a pregnant woman nor a vegetative patient, but a dead body. They argue that, if the present quandary is to be reduced to a two-dimensional law school question, it follows that Marlise must assume the role she would have in a court of law: a legally dead entity. As such, she is not protected under the Texas Advance Directives Act, as the statute — like most other statutes — only applies for the living.
"This patient is neither terminally nor irreversibly ill," Dr. Robert Fine, clinical director of the office of clinical ethics and palliative care for Baylor Health Care System, told reporters last week. "Under Texas law, this patient is legally dead."
In addition, husband Erick Munoz and other critics of the hospital’s stance point to the questionable viability of the unborn fetus that is now entering its 20th week of gestation. Although doctors say they are monitoring the unborn child’s development, Erick, who is also a paramedic, is afraid his wife’s injuries may not be limited to her own body. "You know what kind of damage my wife sustained, and what kind of possible damage the baby inside her sustained," he told reporters.
An Easier Way Out
As we cede these ethical and legal issues to the state judiciary, two things seem clear. First, given the relatively staunch position of both parties, the lawsuit at hand may be the easiest way out of a situation that could otherwise get very messy very quickly. After all, both sides are trying to protect what they value over most things: the hospital is fighting for its patient care policy, and Erick is fighting for the mother of his child. A drawn-out dispute would be in no one’s interest.
Second, while the present suit may be the most sensible option, it risks pitting against each other two parties that really don’t want any trouble at all. There is a case to be made that the hospital, in refusing to pull Marlise’s life support, is not advancing an uncompromising pro-life agenda, but simply hedging itself against third-party litigants. Tom Mayo, a professor of law at Southern Methodist University, told reporters in early January that if the hospital was to honor Marlise’s Do-Not-Resuscitate order, it would itself run the risk of civil and even criminal liability under the Texas Advance Directives Act.
And if such liability would be established, the hospital could face litigation from anti-abortion activists and pro-life groups — foes with longer arms and deeper pockets than a 26-year-old single father who just wants to bury his wife, return to his 15-month-old son, and resume his life as a paramedic in North Texas.
