Girl Brain-Damaged After Eating KFC Twister Dragged Back to Court as Fast Food Giant Fights $8 Million Ruling

KFC
The saga began at this restaurant in the Sydney suburb of Villawood. Tim Wimborne / Reuters

In an ill-advised PR move, fast-food chain Kentucky Fried Chicken is taking a 14-year-old brain-damaged girl and her family back to court. The restaurant wants to get out of paying the family the $8.3 million it was ordered and for their legal bills to be covered.

Monika Samaan's saga began seven years ago. In 2005, she and her family visited a local KFC restaurant near their home in Sydney, where Samaan had a KFC chicken twister. Samaan and her family became ill with salmonella poisoning but she was the only one who did not recover. Samaan's illness was so severe that she slipped into a coma and was hospitalized for several months. Seven years later, the disease has left Samaan unable to speak and confined to a wheelchair.

In April, an Australian court ordered the chicken establishment to pay the family 8 million Australian dollars, or over $8.3 million in damages. As Supreme Court justice Stephen Rothman said in April, Samaan will not be able to have the normal life that it was believed that she would have. The family, who lives in a modest home in the Sydney suburb of Yagoona, says that Samaan's disability has already depleted their limited resources. Their lawyer said that they are finding it difficult to lift their daughter and care for her basic needs, as well as devote attention to their other children.

At the hearing for Samaan's case, employees at the restaurant branch in question reported handling meat without gloves, throwing food around and even serving chicken after it had already fallen on the ground.

But KFC is arguing in their appeal filing that the Samaans visited an anomalous restaurant. Their lawyers are claiming that judges in the initial hearing did not consider some evidence, gave some evidence more weight than it deserved and that the judge's factual findings were erroneous.

Their appeal could mean that the Samaans would not receive some or any of the money that they were awarded earlier this year. The family says that they have not received any of it as of yet. The fast-food corporation also wants the family to pay their legal bills, which would be thousands of dollars.

Join the Discussion